• Banner 3
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 1

Welcome to The Sicilian Butcher

Founded in Phoenix, AZ, The Sicilian Butcher is a trendy Italian-American sandwich joint known for its diverse menu options and unique dining experience. Offering vegan and limited vegetarian choices, along with Happy Hour specials and a full bar, this restaurant caters to a wide range of preferences. Customers rave about the delicious tiramisu, eggplant meatballs, and chicken parmesan. With attentive service and a cozy ambiance, The Sicilian Butcher is a must-visit destination for those craving Italian cuisine with a modern twist.

The Sicilian Butcher: Reviews & Ratings

Isaac R.
Isaac R.

This place is amazing; every time I come to Phoenix, this is a stop I must make. I always leave satisfied with this place. I came with the family, and we got this nice booth. Great customer service, and the tiramisu is one of the best in Arizona I have ever tried.

Randa S.
Randa S.

I have been anxiously awaiting a visit to The Sicilian Butcher after seeing them online. We went in the side door thinking it was the front. Kind of hard to see from the parking lot. We were seated near the bar, but weren't bothered by the traffic. The decor was old style with a warehouse look. The restaurant is very large and very busy. Make a reservation! Our server acknowledged us right away. His name was Jesus. He was very kind and helped with all our questions. The food was delicious for sure! We happened to be there when one of the managers slipped on a wet floor. Her name was Melissa and she assured us she was ok. She is pregnant and we were very concerned for her well being. She was assisted right away and assured us she was ok! Even sent us home with delicious cheesecake. Thank you for a wonderful evening Jesus and Melissa! We will be back.

Sam F.
Sam F.

Whether is special occasion or casual dinner with friends this is the place! Personally, I think it's the best of all of Chef Joey's restaurants. I do not eat meat or in general a big bowl of pasta, but I am such a big fan of the eggplant meat balls and polenta as well as the appetizers and cannolis that I leave feeling 100% satisfied I of course, had to try the pasta which was cooked to perfection, including gnocchi. Presentation is incredible and service is attentive. What more could you want, aside from a more convenient location to other things? Just make this your destination and call it an evening... but don't forget the cannolis! Already ready to return for another crave worthy cannoli and to sample the other pastries!

Briana H.
Briana H.

First time here and came with family. Our server was friendly and helpful. Here's what we ordered Garlic cheese bread: 8/10 pretty pricey and small portion (good for 2/3 people) Wedge salad: 6/10 more like an appetizer. Very small portion. Dressing and toppings were good though. Pasta with meatballs: 6/10 the steak meatballs were a little tough Pasta with arabiatta sauce and sausage meatballs: 8/10 crowd favorite. Sausage meatballs were a little dense but not lacking in flavor. Steak with chimichurri: 8/10 portion a little small for the price Chicken Parmesan: 9/10 WINNING dish. Two people in or party ordered it and said it was delicious. Would have been 10/10 if the pasta portion was bigger Overall, nice cute place. Prices are on the higher end. However, the pasta and meatballs dish is priced well. The pasta is portioned perfectly.

Stephanie W.
Stephanie W.

Matt was amazing as was the food and the vibes! We did the wine and bruschetta board---amazing and a great bargain.

Bill C.
Bill C.

Food was great, and service was excellent. There was a problem with our order and they dealt with it quickly and effectively. Great ambiance indoors and and on the patio! We will be here regularly! Kudos to Amanda - our server!

Amy R.
Amy R.

One of the best in the valley ! Matt was our server and was so attentive and had great recommendations! We'll be back!

Location

Welcome to The Sicilian Butcher, where Italian-American cuisine meets sandwiches in a unique and flavorful experience. Situated at 15530 N Tatum Blvd Ste 160 in Phoenix, AZ, this establishment offers an array of amenities such as delivery, takeout, reservations, vegan and limited vegetarian options, and more. The restaurant boasts a hipster, casual, trendy, and classy atmosphere with moderate noise levels and casual dress attire.

As a food reviewer of Res Menu, I must highlight the diverse range of offerings at The Sicilian Butcher. From happy hour specials to full bar service, this spot caters to all tastes. Noteworthy features include their compostable containers, plastic-free packaging, and reusable tableware, aligning with sustainable practices.

Customer reviews speak volumes about the dining experience at The Sicilian Butcher. Isaac R. raves about the tiramisu, while Randa S. praises the decor and service provided by staff members Jesus and Melissa. Sam F. enjoys the eggplant meatballs and cannolis, attesting to the varied menu. Briana H. provides a detailed analysis of dishes like garlic cheese bread and chicken Parmesan, emphasizing quality and portion sizes.

Stephanie W. commends the wine and bruschetta board, while Bill C. appreciates the prompt resolution of an order issue and the ambiance. Lastly, Amy R. is impressed by the attentive service of server Matt and plans to return for more. These testimonials collectively paint a picture of a restaurant that excels in both cuisine and customer satisfaction.

Personally, I am eager to visit The Sicilian Butcher and indulge in their renowned dishes. The combination of traditional Italian flavors with modern twists intrigues me, and I look forward to sampling their pasta dishes, meatballs, and desserts. With a commitment to sustainability and exceptional service, The Sicilian Butcher stands out as a must-visit establishment in Phoenix.